Fantasy
Islands Travel and Leisure's thirtieth-anniversary issue
this month features "New Classics: The Art Pilgrimage,"
an article by MHC English professor Christopher Benfey, who served
as an art critic for Slate magazine for two years and writes about
art for the New York Times Book Review. In the piece, part of the
issue's theme of "new classics of today's travel, Benfey
examines the trend of the past few decades for museums to "return
to the spirit of nineteenth-century world expositions, a refashioning
based on a commercial model that seems newly appropriate in an increasingly
mercurial marketplace." Benfey arguesusing the redesign
of Berlin's Museumsinsel, the Guggenheim's plans for a new headquarters
in downtown Manhattan and its intent to create branches in Brazil,
and plans for the Musée des Arts Premiers on the site of the
Universal Exposition of 1937 as examplesthat today's museums
are becoming places of fantastic architecture, "wonderland"
exhibition spaces, and showplaces of exotic costumes and objects.
These "global islands," he writes are often disconnected
from their individual locales. He suggests that the museums of the
twenty-first century are being designed not as the traditional massive,
permanent storehouses for the world's treasures, but as institutions
that aspire to "weightlessness and spirituality, impermanence
and constant change." At the conclusion of the piece, Benfey
hints that he is not so sure that museum-goers will appreciate these
"fantasy destinations." Writes Benfey, "Will cultural
pilgrims flock to the reconfigured Museum Island in Berlin or to Jean
Nourvel's tribal retreat on the Island of the Swans? Maybe, for a
few years. But then there will be a hunger for newer Islands, in ever
more exotic or gritty' locales." The April 2001 issue of
Travel and Leisure featured another piece by Benfey, this time a look
at the history and spirit of Saratoga Springs.