By STEPHEN KINZER
ISTANBUL, Feb. 14 -- A growing scandal stemming
from a
crackdown on a religious terror group has led to
accusations that the
group may have received weapons from the Turkish government.
In a series of raids that began last month, the police
have found 56
gruesomely tortured bodies buried at hideouts used by
the group, called
Hizbullah. There was another raid today in the eastern
provincial capital
of Van, resulting in a shootout in which five police
officers and two
suspected militants were killed.
Soon after the first bodies were discovered, several
leading politicians
and news commentators charged that Hizbullah had worked
with the
military in its war against rebels among the Kurdish
ethnic group in
eastern Turkey. Military commanders denied the charges.
New evidence has emerged in recent days suggesting
that Hizbullah used
weapons that were imported by the governor of a province
in the heart of
the war zone.
"Since there are weapons missing, they could
have ended up anywhere,"
Prime Minister Bulent Ecevit said. "This is an
extremely serious situation,
and it is being investigated with the seriousness it
deserves."
Civil service investigators said the man who was
governor of the mostly
Kurdish province of Batman in the mid-1990's, Salih
Sarman, might be
charged with "establishing an armed unit without
permission." Governors
in Turkey are appointed by the central government.
According to press reports, a cache of weapons --
including at least 443
automatic rifles, 115 rockets and 1,450 hand grenades
-- that was sent
to Batman by the Turkish government is missing. Newspapers
have
reported that many of those weapons were given to Hizbullah.
During the 1990's, Hizbullah militants were believed
to have killed many
suspected members of the rebel Kurdistan Workers Party,
known as the
P.K.K., the initials of its name in Kurdish. The government
was then
involved in a no-holds-barred war against the rebels.
Military commanders have denied that they gave weapons
to Hizbullah.
"The Turkish armed forces have never had a relationship
with any
terrorist organization and will never have such a relationship,"
Gen. Atila
Isik asserted.
Thousands of suspected political killings were committed
in Kurdish
provinces during the war. In Batman Province alone,
there were at least
363 such "mystery killings," none of which
have been solved. Another 43
people are listed as missing.
Newspapers have charged that Tansu Ciller, who was
Turkey's prime
minister in 1995 and 1996, authorized local officials
in the Kurdish region
to distribute weapons to terror groups that opposed
the rebels.
Mrs. Ciller has admitted that she ordered weapons
delivered to the
Batman governor, which was an unusual step, since weapons
are
normally sent only to military units. She said that
her order had been
approved by the military chief of staff and senior police
officials, and that
she was "glad today that we took those actions
then."
"We met and made a decision," Mrs. Ciller
said. "We agreed that terror
was the top issue, and that we had to do whatever was
necessary. It was
not possible to act otherwise. We had to do everything
possible, and we
did."
President Suleyman Demirel said military commanders
had assured him
that all weapons in Batman could be been accounted for.
But he said that
some of the weapons might have been given to paramilitary
village
guards, and that "from there they may have found
their way to other
places."
"The state is not always obliged to follow routine,"
Mr. Demirel said. "It
can deviate from routine when higher interests require
it, if the
government approves."
Those statements provoked strong protests from several
politicians. One
of them, Salih Yildirim, a prominent member of Parliament,
said: "The
Constitution specifies what the state may and may not
do. Anyone who
acts outside these limits is committing a crime."
A retired general, Nevzat Bolugiray, told an Istanbul
magazine that he
believed that Hizbullah might have received government
weapons, but
that the transfer had not been approved by military
commanders.
"Some people who see themselves as patriots
formed what amounts to a
terrorist group," General Bolugiray said. "I
believe there may have been
government officials who used Hizbullah against the
P.K.K. This creates
the appearance that it was official state policy, but
in my opinion it was
actually an action taken by certain individuals."
Reports of how the government fought Kurdish rebels
in Batman have
led to a series of revelations about actions taken in
other Kurdish
provinces. Newspapers have reported that in 1994 the
governor of Van,
a province where rebels were also active, approved formation
of a secret
unit made up of 18 Kurdish-speaking soldiers.
The soldiers posed as rebels, apparently seeking
to find out which
families or villages would sympathize with them. They
also harassed local
peasants, demanding money, weapons and volunteers.
The unit's roughness was apparently too persuasive.
It was ambushed
outside the village of Diyadin by a squad of village
guards loyal to the
government. Eight of its members were killed and another
nine were
wounded.