By STEPHEN KINZER
STANBUL, Turkey -- When the Kurdish rebel leader
Abdullah
Ocalan was captured in February and brought to prison
in chains,
many Turks celebrated jubilantly. Now they are finding
that his case
could bar their way to Europe.
A Turkish court has sentenced Ocalan to hang, but
in Europe the death
penalty is considered barbaric. On Tuesday the European
Court of
Human Rights asked Turkey to delay Ocalan's execution
until it finishes
reviewing the case, which could take a year or longer.
Turks are being given an early taste of how much
national sovereignty
they will lose if they reach their long-sought goal
of joining the European
Union.
At a summit meeting in Helsinki, Finland, next week,
European leaders
will make a possibly crucial decision on whether to
accept Turkey as an
official candidate for membership in the union. They
have already warned
that whatever they decide, Turkey's prospects will collapse
if Ocalan is
executed.
"It's not only about Ocalan," said Prime
Minister Paavo Lipponen of
Finland, whose government holds the rotating chairmanship
of the
European Union. "It's about the death sentence.
The death sentence does
not belong in Europe."
Nationalism is strong in Turkey, but so is desire
to join the European
Union. One of these impulses will have to weaken if
the other is to
survive.
The government is divided over how to proceed. Prime
Minister Bulent
Ecevit opposes the death penalty, but Deputy Prime Minister
Devlet
Bahceli, who heads the right-wing Nationalist Action
party, favors it.
"Linking Turkey's membership in the EU to a
terrorist chieftain is quite
upsetting," Bahceli said in a speech this week.
"This attitude is not only an
insult and injustice to Turkey, but also brings shame
on the EU itself."
Behind statements like those lie profound misgivings
about how fervently
Turkey should pursue its campaign to join the European
Union. The
misgivings are being voiced more frequently now that
the union seems
ready to make Turkey an official candidate.
"If we get rid of the death penalty, they will
say our environmental laws
are not strong enough," said Altemur Kilic, a retired
diplomat who is a
member of Nationalist Action. "Then, after we change
the environmental
laws, they will say we don't protect homosexual rights.
It will go on and
on and on. I disagree with my intellectual friends who
are ready to give
up our independence in order to enter the European Union.
We were not
born with Europe and we won't die without Europe."
Many Turks, however, view membership in the European
Union as a
huge prize that would solidify the country's shaky democracy
and
guarantee its future prosperity.
"Keeping Ocalan alive is in Turkey's best interests,"
said Mehmet Ali
Irtemcelik, a cabinet minister whose portfolio includes
human rights and
European affairs. He said that carrying out the death
sentence would
prevent Turkey from reaching "extraordinarily bright
horizons."
"We can't allow Ocalan to be a shackle around
our ankle in the era
ahead," Irtemcelik said. "If you look at this
as an Ocalan problem, you'll
be jumping into a canoe of emotions and will get carried
downstream."
Even if Turkey succeeds at the summit meeting next
week and is selected
as an official candidate for membership in the European
Union, it will
have far to go before it can be admitted. Thousands
of laws and
regulations, affecting matters from press freedom to
the size of bananas,
would have to be changed to conform with European standards.
That process could take many years, and would certainly
arouse the
passion of Turkish nationalists. It would also illustrate
a fundamental fact
about the European Union that is not widely understood
here: that joining
this exclusive club requires what may be the most sweeping
voluntary
surrender of sovereignty in the history of the nation-state.
European leaders have already begun reminding Turkey
of this reality.
Foreign Minister Jozias van Aartsen of the Netherlands
met with Turkish
leaders in Ankara on Monday, and said afterward that
if Turkey wants to
join the European Union, it must improve its human rights
record, curb
the power of the military in politics, change its approach
to minorities and
make new overtures to Greece.
"We are interested in what will happen after
Helsinki," van Aartsen said.
"There must be a period of improvements."