Physics 301 Fall 2001

Imaging with a Lens

Introduction

We will explore the image-forming properties of lenses. Thin lenses can be grouped into two categories, positive (converging) lenses, and negative (diverging) lenses. A positive lens is one that causes incident parallel rays to converge at a focal point on the opposite side of the lens. A negative lens is one that causes incident parallel rays to emerge from the lens as though they emanated from a focal point on the incident side of the lens. The two types of lenses are illustrated below.

The distance from the lens to the focal point is called the focal length, and considered negative in the case of a negative lens.

If you select a lens by clicking it, the focal points are indicated by white dots at the focal length on either side of the lens. You can drag the focal point with the mouse to see the effect of changing the focal length.

Use the mouse to determine the position of the lens and of the focal point. The difference in these positions should be the focal length. Select the lens by clicking on it: the focal length f will be shown. Is it about what you expected?

The parallel rays in the figures above represent a point source infinitely far away to the left. (This is a tricky concept! Think about it.) More generally, light rays emanating from any point (the "object") on the central axis will be brought to a focus (the "image", real or virtual) at some other point on the central axis. If the object is not at infinity, but at the finite position p, then a lens of focal length f forms an image at the position q determined by the thin lens equation

Here it is understood that p is measured from the center of the lens, and is considered positive if the object is to the left of the lens, and negative to the right. Similarly q is measured from the center of the lens and is positive to the right of the lens, negative to the left (opposite sign convention from p). What is q in the special case that p goes to infinity? (Compare the figures at the top of this page.)

Experiment with the setup pictured below by dragging the object (source of the light rays) with the mouse. Note that when the object is off-axis the image is off-axis too. If the object is not too far off-axis, then the distances p, q, and f are still given by the thin-lens equation. This determines the horizontal position of the image. The vertical distance of the image from the axis is most easily determined by the special ray through the center of the lens, which is undeviated: as you move the object vertically, the image also moves vertically as if at the opposite end of a lever which pivots at the center of the lens. Try to make sense of these statements in the figure below, and in particular check the thin lens equation.

Now replace the "source" in the applet with an "object" (meaning an object of finite extent). The way to do this is to select the source by clicking on it, then push the "Clear Active" button. The active element, that is, the source you selected, should disappear. Now push the "Object" button and click where you want to place the new object (roughly where the source used to be). If necessary, drag the new object a little off-axis so that you can see it better. The object is indicated by a vertical arrow, and the image of the tip of the arrow is constructed by ray-tracing. Only three rays are drawn, but they are enough to see where the image is, and they are the simplest rays, or, as they are called, the principal rays. Notice that the one through the center of the lens is undeviated, and the other two go through the focal points of the lens (select the lens by clicking on it to see this).

Drag the object around and notice how the image behaves. As the object approaches the focal point of the lens, the image retreats to infinity (note the parallel rays). What happens if you bring the object inside the focal length of the lens? Something very interesting! The image reappears as a virtual image on the same side of the lens as the object (i.e., q is now negative: check how the thin lens equation describes this). An eye looking in from the right would receive rays as if from this image. It is called "virtual" because you have to extrapolate the rays backward to find it: the light rays themselves don't actually intersect to form a "real" image. By the way, in this configuration the lens is acting as a magnifying glass: think why this is.

It makes sense to compare the size of the object and the image. We define the magnification M to be the ratio of the size I of the image to the size O of the object, but by similar triangles this is also the ratio of the image distance q to the object distance p:

The minus sign is a sign convention: it is there so that the magnification will be positive if the image is erect, and negative if the image is inverted. Note that the magnification can be either greater or less than one in magnitude.

Procedure:

Determination of focal length:

In this experiment you will measure the focal length of two converging lenses using two different methods. For each measurement, record the focal length along with estimated errors in your lab notebook. The experimental setup consists of an optical rail along which a light source, screen, and mounted lens can travel in a straight line. The rail is grated so that the object and image distances can be measured directly off the rail. The light source contains a white square with two crossed arrows and will serve as the object for the majority of the experiment.

Method 1:

Select two dissimilar converging lenses. From the thin lens equation we know that the image distance, q, is approximately equal to the focal length, f, when the object distance, p, is very large. We can use this observation to approximate the focal length of a lens. With each lens, attempt to image a distant object (the sun, overhead lights, distant buildings) and classify the lens as either converging or diverging. Determine the focal lengths of the converging lenses by measuring the distance between the center of the lens and the location of the image. Which lens has the longer focal length? Which lens forms the larger image of a distant object? Which lens forms the brighter image? What factors do you think determine the brightness?

Method 2:

Place the light source at one end of the optical rail. Place the screen on the other end of the rail and a converging lens between the light source and the screen. By moving either the lens or the screen or both, focus an image of the crossed arrows on the screen. Measure the object distance, image distance, object size and image size (and orientation). Repeat for a total of 5 distinct object distances spread over a range of 1.5f to 4f. Determine the focal length of the lens by making a plot of 1/q vs. 1/p. The focal length of the lens can be determined from the equation of the best fit line. How does this compare to your value from method 1? Which method gives more accurate results? Calculate the magnification at each object distance using two different methods: first using the image and object size, then using the image and object distances. How do these two values compare? Repeat the above procedure for the second positive lens. With an image focused on the screen, slide the screen back and forth along the optical bench. Observe carefully how the colors of the border change as the image passes through the point of focus. The index of refraction of the lens unfortunately depends on the wavelength of the light. As a result the focal length of the lens, ultimately determined by ray tracing and Snell's Law, is slightly different for each wavelength. Since our white light source is made up of all wavelengths, different colors are focused at slightly different image distances. This is referred to as chromatic aberration of a lens.