These men are cookies.
Get out your milk glasses, folks.
| Duncan MacLeod of the Clan MacLeod. The eternal boy scout. (Adrian Paul) | Peanut Butter |
| Angel (David Boreanaz) | Sugar |
| Oz (Seth Green) | Chocolate Chocolate Chunk (no wussy chips for our werewolf) |
| Spike (James Marsters) | Ginger Snap (the cookie that bites back) |
| Chauvelin (Rex Smith) | Chocolate |
| Neil Perry (Robert Sean Leonard) | Molasses |
| Todd Anderson (Ethan Hawke) | Butter |
| Tristan Thorne | Chocolate Vanilla Sandwich |
| Alan Mendelsohn, the boy from Mars | White Chocolate Macadamia nut |