Astronomy 23/223 Homework:

What is a Planet, Anyway?


Over the last few years there has been a great controversy over the subject of how you define what counts as a planet. To get you warmed up and think about planets, this week's homework focuses on this issue. Here are links to a few articles on this subject.

IAU Resolution B5

IAU Q&A on Planets

Pluto and the Solar System

Two articles from the New York Times about Pluto: 1 2

What to Call the Little Planet, Sky and Telescope, May 1999, by Beatty
color (but small)

The Puzzles of Planethood, Sky and Telescope, August 2002, by Denise Kaisler
color

Toward a Planet Paradigm, Sky and Telescope, August 2002, by Stern and Levison
color

For this week’s homework:

 

I’d like you to research the controversy of how to define a planet. In 2-3 pages (no more than 3 pages!), create a definition of a planet (dictionairy definition will not surfice), support your definition with evidence from the articles, and explain if Pluto should or should not qualify as a planet by your definition. Please cite your sources. If you have any questions about how to cite sources check this website or ask me.

 

 

Home | Syllabus | Course Schedule | Images and Data | Homework | Homework Answers
In-Class Exercises | In-Class Answers | Exam Review | Exam Answers | Student List | Contact Darby

| Summer Internships | More on Astronomy| Bus Schedule

This page was created by Darby Dyar and is maintained by Darby Dyar and Rebekah Robson-May.
Last updated on 14 September, 2008 .