Your Email address
Name of the Student Evaluated
What was the thesis of the presentation? (If there was no clear thesis,
write "thesis unclear"):
Did the student demonstrate how her thesis fits into an existing
debate within the literature?
Was it clear why the above thesis was chosen?
To what extent did the logic of the presentation support the thesis?
What theoretical framework was the presentation grounded within (e.g.
neoclassical, Marxian, institutionalist)?
What were the most interesting and/or provocative points made during
What should have been done differently?