The case against reopening schools

Rose Levine is a fifth-grade teacher who graduated from Mount Holyoke College's Professional and Graduate Education program with a master's in teaching

By Keely Sexton

With a clear-sighted critique of remote teaching, Rose Levine, a fifth grade teacher and dual alumna of Mount Holyoke, eviscerated the idea that returning to physical classrooms amid the COVID-19 pandemic would benefit students. 

Levine graduated from Mount Holyoke College in 2006 with a bachelor of arts degree in biological illustration and a master’s of arts in teaching degree from the Professional and Graduate Education’s teaching program. Her opinion article was published in a Washington Post article titled “The case against reopening schools during the pandemic — by a fifth-grade teacher.” 

In the piece, Levine discussed the difficult challenges of remote teaching, including technological gaps and isolation. She argued that a rush to return to in-person teaching with safety protocols such as masks and physical distancing is a misguided attempt to recapture what has been lost in the move away from physical classrooms. 

“Sharing a classroom allows our elementary cohorts to become like family,” Levine wrote. “We play games, exchange smiles, sit in circles on the rug and tell stories. We taste each other’s food and whisper in each other’s ears. We have casual exchanges during downtimes at recess or transitions between subjects. We share supplies, collaborate and take turns, and in so doing we build a model of accountability to one another and our community.”

She also addressed the argument that at-risk children, those who live under threat of abuse, neglect or hunger, would be better served by a return to school.

“[C]ounterintuitive as it may seem, bringing children back into the building that has served as their refuge may actually serve to exacerbate and heighten their trauma,” she said. “Virtual school poses great risks for our most marginalized and vulnerable children. But returning to school under these conditions may hurt them even more.”

Read the article.

Related News

Gay pride and trans pride flags at the Stonewall National Monument. Grace.Mahony, CC BY-SA 4.0

Beyond the binary: creating inclusive classes

Mount Holyoke’s graduate program is working to ensure that teachers can create inclusive curricula and classrooms.

Two students and one faculty member looking at a tablet in a classroom setting.

Neal funding to help local schools post-COVID

Mount Holyoke’s Professional and Graduate Education division awarded $250,000 to help local teachers and students with post-pandemic transitions.

this is a photo of two students working together on their respective laptops.

MHC partners with independent schools

The new initiative targets HBCUs, Hispanic-serving institutions and tribal colleges and universities to develop a robust and diverse teacher pipeline.

This is a formal portrait of Jemelleh Coes. She is smiling, wearing a pearl necklace.

Inspired by a Black female SCOTUS justice

Jemelleh Coes, director of teacher leadership at Mount Holyoke, talks about her hopes of having a Black female justice on the U.S. Supreme Court.

Professional and Graduate Education graphic with outline of a graduation cap

MHC ranks for online programs

Mount Holyoke’s graduate programs in education have ranked in the top half of 2022’s “Best Online Programs” according to U.S. News & World Report.

Find more stories >