Separating the art from the artist

Art, more than ordinary objects, is often associated with the moral character of their creators, says James Harold, professor of philosophy at Mount Holyoke. His new book explores the ramifications of that association.

By Christian Feuerstein

Controversies about “separating the art from the artist” have been raging for decades. Today it’s J.K. Rowling, H.P. Lovecraft, Bill Cosby and R. Kelly; in the past, heated discussions have centered on works by Hitler, Salvador Dalí and Richard Wagner. 

James Harold, chair of philosophy at Mount Holyoke College, has a new book that tackles the question head on. In “Dangerous Art: On Moral Criticism of Artworks,” he explores whether art can be morally evaluated and what this means for the value of the artwork itself.

In a blog post for the book’s publisher, Oxford University Press, Harold wrote: “Art, more than ordinary objects, is often associated with the moral character of their creators. For example, Confucius claimed that the music of the great sage-king Shun was superior to the music of lesser kings.” He then writes that such inclinations aren’t rational, though they are widespread.

Harold then explores the work of “affective communities” in evaluating artists and their works. Affective communities, Harold explained, are “communities of people who care about a work of art, and so come to see one another as members of a community. Caring about an artwork brings the audience into a relationship with others who love the same work, and sometimes with the artist her- or himself. Some of these communities are well-known and clearly established: Bloomsday, the Harry Potter ‘Wizarding World,’ Trekkies, and so on.”

These communities, he wrote, “make the moral character of the artist particularly salient to enjoyment of the artwork.”

Read the blog post.

Related News

Mount Holyoke student Kylie Gellatly FP’23 has published her first collection of poetry, “The Fever Poems.”

Kylie Gellatly publishes “The Fever Poems”

Mount Holyoke student Kylie Gellatly FP’23 has published her first collection of poetry, “The Fever Poems.” 

Image by David Driskell. Silence from the Doorway Portfolio, 2008 Reductive serigraph, Partial gift of Curlee Raven Holton and purchase with the Ann Nelson Behrman ’54 Art Acquisition Fund, 2012.49.3, © Estate of David C. Driskell.

Students present at Mount Holyoke conference

Mount Holyoke College students presented at a College-organized Black Studies and Romanticism conference.

Benjamin Gebre-Medhin

Toward more equitable admissions

Mount Holyoke professor’s research finds that college admissions essays are even more strongly linked to socioeconomic status than test scores.

Jerrine Tan

No more gaslighting anti-Asian hate

Jerrine Tan, visiting lecturer in English at Mount Holyoke, writes for Wired magazine about her 14 years of second-guessing the racism directed at her.

Crafting a Life in the Arts in rainbow colored letters.

Crafting a full life in the arts

Mount Holyoke’s event Crafting a Life in the Arts shows students that the COVID-19 pandemic shouldn’t deter a sustaining life in the arts. 

Find more stories >