Toward more equitable admissions

Ben Gebre-Medhin, Assistant Professor of Sociology

By Keely Savoie Sexton 

In a bid to make their admissions processes more equitable, many colleges and universities have stopped requiring standardized testing, because student scores are strongly tied to their socioeconomic status. 

But Benjamin Gebre-Medhin, assistant professor of sociology, recently co-authored a study that suggests that eliminating test requirements is only the beginning of making college admissions more equitable. 

Gebre-Medhin and the research team used computational text analysis to determine the relationship between essay content and household income. They found that essay content was even more strongly associated with household income than SAT scores.

“Our findings lead us to conclude that doing away with standardized testing, while a potentially laudable step that some pioneering colleges like Mount Holyoke have taken, can only go so far toward realizing a truly equitable admissions process,” said Gebre-Medhin.

A number of news outlets have covered this research, including The Economist and Fox News. The editorial board of the Wall Street Journal used the findings to argue that basing college admissions on “‘soft’ rather than numerical criteria won’t be more equitable or progressive.” This interpretation, Gebre-Medhin believes, misconstrues the struggle for fairness and equity in college admissions.

“Any meaningful admissions reform must acknowledge the powerful and pervasive manner in which family resources and privilege condition access to the things that are valued in the academy,” he said. 

“Earning a college degree is an important step toward economic security in the contemporary economy. Until well-resourced, affordable and high-quality post-secondary education is broadly accessible to all qualified students in America, conditions of scarcity are likely to intensify inequality no matter what measures of merit are used in college admissions.”

Related News

Carmen Yulín Cruz, former mayor of San Juan and distinguished fellow at Mount Holyoke College, reflects on the four-year anniversary of Hurricane Maria.

Hope for the displaced

Carmen Yulín Cruz, former mayor of San Juan and distinguished fellow at Mount Holyoke College, reflects on the four-year anniversary of Hurricane Maria.

Corey Flanders

Biphobia linked to intimate partner violence

Research conducted by Corey Flanders, assistant professor at Mount Holyoke, links intimate partner violence in the bi community to biphobia. 

One woman congratulates the other on her award

Breaking geographical and academic boundaries

Suparna Roychoudhury, associate professor of English, brings an expansive passion for knowledge to her teaching and scholarship at Mount Holyoke.

Marcella Runell Hall

Sophomore year, first-year questions

Mount Holyoke’s Marcella Runell Hall discussed reorienting this year’s sophomores alongside new first-year students with the Boston Globe.

Photo of Amber Douglas

Investing in student success

Amber Douglas has been named Mount Holyoke’s Dean of the College and will lead a new student success division.

Find more stories >