When all Latinx immigrants become “Mexicans”

David Hernández is associate professor of Latina/o studies at Mount Holyoke College

By Keely Sexton

Mexicans have long been the scapegoats of anti-immigrationists in the United States. But shifts in immigration rhetoric have led to the conflation of all Latinx identities with Mexicans — and the result is both policy and public discourse grounded in racism and xenophobia, wrote David Hernández in an article for the Radical History Review’s Abusable Past Forum. 

In the post, Hernández, associate professor of Latina/o studies at Mount Holyoke College, cited the infamous March 2019 Fox News blunder, when “Trump cuts aid to 3 Mexican countries” was the onscreen caption for a report about the Trump Administration’s decision to cut aid to El Salvador, Guatemala and Honduras. While it may have been a mistake, the caption belied some deeper truths about the history of what “Mexican” means in the United States. 

“The concept of ‘3 Mexican countries’ both flows from and inspires the sweeping racial statements and actions of the president and his followers,” wrote Hernández. “Recall that although the El Paso mass shooter sought to stem the ‘Hispanic invasion of Texas,’ he also told police he traveled to El Paso to shoot ‘Mexicans’ explicitly.” 

The intentional and unintentional (though revealing) blurring of Latinx identities into a single monolithic “Mexican” community, despite major shifts in Latinx migration in the last decade, is a “repeated tool of anti-immigrant policymakers,” wrote Hernández. 

“Sweeping, undifferentiated racial categories — which have a long presence in immigration history… — are the abusive tools of marketers, media hucksters, politicians, and mass shooters.”

Read the story.

Related News

Adam Hilton in his office at Mount Holyoke College

The Republican Party’s radicalization

Mount Holyoke College Assistant Professor of Politics Adam Hilton talked to The Boston Globe about the radicalization of Republicans.  

Andy Reiter, associate professor of politics and international relations, discussing Venezuela on WGBY’s Connecting Point.

A truth commission doomed to fail

Mount Holyoke Associate Professor Andrew Reiter argues that the U.S. doesn’t have the conditions for a successful commission on the Capitol insurrection. 

This is a picture of Elizabeth Gómez Alcorta, who leads Argentina’s Ministry of Women, Gender and Diversity.

Expanding women’s rights around the world

Mount Holyoke’s Cora Fernandez Anderson spoke with Argentina’s Elizabeth Gómez Alcorta, who leads Argentina’s Ministry of Women, Gender and Diversity.

Mara Benjamin in her office, looking at the camera

Mob at Capitol was an “attempted putsch”

Mount Holyoke College Professor Mara Benjamin was part of a group of Jewish scholars who called for Trump’s removal after January’s Capitol breach.  

Jelani Cobb in his study, smiling at the camera and surrounded by books and a computer screen.

Jelani Cobb on the half-life of freedom

As part of Mount Holyoke’s Martin Luther King Jr. and Coretta Scott King Week of Racial Justice and Reconciliation, Jelani Cobb will give a public lecture.

Find more stories >