by David Holt

Guidelines for Philosophical Discussion
by Rachel Brauser

, by Janell Cannon, has a lot to offer to a philosophical discussion on identity, making promises, the difference between being and feeling, and family. The question sets encourage children to explore what makes up one's identity, preservation and changing of identity, how being and feeling affect relationships and identity, what makes up a family, why people make and break promises, and what kinds of promises there are. All the question sets are intended to combine these themes in order to guide an engaging philosophical discussion. While thinking about issues in their own lives and hearing about others they may find that what seems to be a simple question will not have a simple answer, therefore encouraging them to think more critically and to always question the answers whether it be their own or others'.

Question sets A through D integrate the issue of identity in some way. Figuring out one's own identity is one of the most complicated processes children go through. Through one's own strengths and limitations, and influences of others, this identity is shaped. Stellaluna struggles with this same idea because of her strengths and limitations as a bat and and their effects on her relationship to other bats and the bird family. Stellaluna also struggles with maintaining identity while adjusting to different surroundings and animals. The questions will guide the children in exploring their own identity in terms of how it is created, how other people affect it, if and how it can be maintained, and if and how it can change.

Question sets A and B raise the issue of the difference between being and feeling. Philosophers have often grappled with ideas of complexity of the self. Set A explores this issue specifically within one's own identity. in relation to one's identity. Set B explores this issue in terms of identity in relation to others. These questions will give children the opportunity to try to understand and create concepts of being and feeling by exploring their identity in terms of thoughts, feelings, and physical appearance.

Question set C raises the issue of maintaining identity while obeying rules. It also explores the idea of belonging to a group and how that affects identity. These ethical issues will lead the children to discuss whether identity can be maintained while belonging to a group and whether it should. This ties directly into question set four where ideas of what and who makes up a family can be discussed. The children will do this by comparing their own families to other families and Stellaluna's.

The last two sets, E and F, raise the issue of promises. The children will explore kinds of promises and whether there is a difference between them. They will also discuss why people make them and why they break them and whether this is ever acceptable. This will give the children the opportunity to think more critically about the effects and importance of promises they make to others.

Continue to question set for this story